Skip Discover Education Main Navigation

9-12 > U.S. History

A Nation's Voice
A Nation’s Voice
 
Grade Level  9-12
Subject Area  U.S. history

Curriculum Focus
  U.S. government
Duration  1-2 weeks

Objective
  Students will:
  1. Understand U.S. policy making in times of military conflict by learning about constitutional, statutory, and customary factors that affect policy.
  2. Apply their knowledge of policy making to determine if U.S. involvement in one its 20th century conflicts was warranted.


Materials
  Information sources including Internet sites, magazines and books, electronic encyclopedias and databases; access to the Constitution and the War Powers Act, world political and physical maps.

Procedure
  The Constitution and the War Powers Act have clear instructions regarding the authority of the president and the Congress. Yet, U.S. presidents have committed troops to battle more than 100 times without a formal declaration of war from Congress. Were they justified?
  1. Engage
Start by asking your students to consider the following quotation and discuss the questions below.

“Laws are silent in time of war.”
Marcus Tullius Cicero (106-43 B.C.E.),
Roman orator, poet, and statesman

What examples in U.S. history support or refute Cicero’s claim?

What can you conclude from this statement?

  2. Explore
i.Have students use the Constitution and the War Powers Act to determine what the powers of government are in times of conflict (see related links below and be sure to bookmark this page for convenience).

Facts they should arrive at are:

    Article I, Section 8 of the U.S. Constitution gives Congress
    the right to declare war and raise and support military forces.

    Article II, Section 2 of the U.S. Constitution states that the
    president shall be commander in chief of U.S. military forces.

    The War Powers Act of 1973 limits the president’s ability to
    use military forces by requiring him to report the use of troops
    to Congress within 48 hours and allowing him to continue their
    use for only 60 days without congressional authorization.

ii.Have students discuss and cite historic examples for the following customary factors surrounding the committal of military troops:

    Few members of Congress will challenge a successful military
    operation.

    The United States often sends troops into hostile situations as
    part of UN operations.

    The views of foreign policy elites and military leaders are very
    important in shaping policy in times of conflict, as are national
    security concerns.

    Popular opinion is an important influence on the president and
    Congress in times of conflict, although the government does
    not always do what the public wants (example: Congress
    continued to appropriate funds for the conflict in Vietnam even
    after it became unpopular).

iii.Ask students to select one of the following conflicts to investigate further. You may wish to have them work individually or you might break the students into groups that will research each of the conflicts together. To hear the audio files, you need the RealPlayer plug-in.Downloadit now.

The Declaration of War on Japan
Franklin D. Roosevelt
Sound 14.4 kbps
Sound 28.8 kbps
(running time: 7:44)

The Cuban Missile Crisis
John F. Kennedy
Sound 14.4 kbps
Sound 28.8 kbps
(running time: 7:31)

Operation Desert Storm
George Bush
Sound 14.4 kbps
Sound 28.8 kbps
(running time: 6:33)

Other conflict choices include the Korean War, the Vietnam War, President Reagan’s invasion of Grenada, President Bush’s invasion of Panama, and President Clinton’s use of NATO forces in Kosovo.

iv.Students should focus their research on the following questions.

  1. Why and how did the conflict begin?
  2. What was the role of the United States in the conflict?
  3. Did the president and Congress act in accordance with the Constitution and the War Powers Act? Was a formal declaration of war made? Did the president report to Congress?
  4. What was the president’s view of and role in the conflict?
  5. How did Congress view and support the use of troops in the conflict?
  6. Were U.S. troops part of UN or NATO forces?
  7. Who were the key policy makers in Washington? Who were the key military leaders involved? How did they influence U.S. policies?
  8. Were there any U.S. interests or national security concerns that determined U.S. actions?
  9. What was popular opinion of the conflict and U.S. involvement in it?
  10. How was the conflict covered in the media?

  3. Elaborate
If students are working individually, ask them to write a legal brief supporting or condemning the president’s actions in the conflict they researched. Each legal brief should contain:

Date—when troops were sent in.

Parties—those involved in the conflict.

Background—political and social climate surrounding the incident.

Discussion—key events that lead to U.S. military involvement and/or continued involvement.

Decision—the legal and political argument for or against the president’s actions in the chosen situation. This should be supported with the research from step 2.

If students are working in groups, have some of the group members write a brief supporting the president’s actions and some write a brief condemning his actions.


Closure
  Student teams should deliver their briefs before a “court” of their peers. Ask the students sitting as members of the court to assume the following roles: the Supreme Court, the public, Congress, and the media. Once the team has read the brief aloud, those acting as the court may ask questions of the team. After qustioning, the court will discuss the verdict briefly and announce it. Was the United States provoked? Were the president’s actions legal? Were they justified under the circumstances?

Extension
  Have students post their legal briefs on a school Web page.

Background
  In 1973 Congress passed the War Powers Act—over presidential veto—to try to limit presidential use of troops without congressional authorization. However, no president has ever acknowledged the constitutionality of the War Powers Act. And the requirements for the president to report to Congress within 48 hours and limit the use of troops to 60 days have never been tested in the courts. The act’s provisions require the following:
  • The president must report in writing to Congress within 48 hours after sending troops into a hostile situation.
  • Congress must provide for the continuation of the use of troops within 60 days by a formal declaration of war or other statutory authorization.
  • If Congress does not authorize the continued use of troops within 60 days, the president must withdraw the troops.
  • If Congress passes a concurrent resolution directing the president to remove the troops, he must comply.
Teachers may wish to note that other provisions of the law regarding the use of a legislative veto were struck down by the Supreme Court in the Chadha case. Since the War Powers Act was passed, presidents have reported to Congress a number of times—in conflicts with Cambodia, Iran, Lebanon, Grenada, and Panama, for example.


Related Links
  The Constitution of the United States of America
The War Powers Act of 1973

Credits
  Our thanks to Lara Maupin, a history teacher at Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology in Alexandria, Virginia, for her consultation.