Enter Username
Access resources you have created under your login.

Teacher Tools such as:
Lesson Plan Creator, Quiz Builder, and Worksheet Generator are no longer available.


You can create new lesson plans and quizzes within your DE streaming account. If you don't have an account, sign up for a demo here.
Favorites
Browse the Brain Boosters Gallery

 

  Logic
 
What a Genius! Or What? A Genius?
 
Q "It seems that all great geniuses have terrible handwriting," said Ralph, looking at a photograph of Albert Einstein's signature.

"Hey," thought Wanda to herself, "my teachers are always complaining that they can't read my handwriting. If all geniuses have terrible handwriting, I must be a genius!"

What do you think? Is Wanda really a genius? If not, what is wrong with her reasoning?


 
A From the way Wanda uses logic, she's definitely not a genius. The fact that Individual A shares one characteristic of a group of individuals does not logically imply that Individual A is a member of that group.

Think of it this way. If Ralph had said, "All whales are good swimmers," Wanda would probably not have thought to herself, "Hey, I've always been a good swimmer. I must be a whale!" On the other hand, if Ralph had said, "All good swimmers are whales," Wanda would have had to assume either that she really was a whale or that Ralphie's statement was false.